Match Player Ratings

[the jock]

madine was actually getting enough time to chest balls from the kickout. that shouldnt be happening.

[Salvatore Matrecano]

Madine spent most of the match rolling on the floor pretending to be in agony if someone brushed against him. Disgraceful player, ref should have booked him for simulation. Thankfully he couldnt score in a brothel anyway.

[PsychoStanleyStone]

Samba 6 - Steady, as Jock says couldn't do much about the goal
Cash 6 - Steady. Not as threatening as usual, but had our best attempt on target
Figs 4 - Madine handed his arse to him. Didn't play badly, was just outplayed/outmuscled.
Worrall 8 - MOTM, another top game.
Robinson 7 - Good performance, as Jock says deserves to keep his place
Watson 7 - Does what he does
Silva 6 - Thought he did well in a role which isn't really his role.
Ameobi 6  - Threatened at times, but his lack of quality was there to see.
Lolley 6 - Poor first half, better second half and seemed to get better as the game went on.
Carvalho 3 - Crap. Waste of a shirt yesterday.
Grabban 6 - Did what he could with what he got. Did well when having  to drop deeper

Semedo 5 - Did OK with what little time he had. Made more of an impact through the fact we now has 3 men in the middle putting it about instead of 2.
Adomah 6 - Did fine with what little time he had. Had he gotten another 20 or so minutes I think one of those crosses would have found a mark.
Mir 4 - Does what Mir does. Nothing lol.

Samba 32 - He should of taken a page out of the others books, should of shot more often, would of scored
Cash    32 - Hard grafter, another day would of set up 10 goals, rasping shot, parried, should of scored
Figs     32 - Compared to the others, far to shot shy, tough game but coped well
Worrall 32 - Sound and solid and dependable Needs to think about shooting, basically, should of scored
Robinson 33 - MOTM consistent, wins the ball, does the basics, battles and good energy, Should of scored, best technically executed curler
Watson  32 - Should of hit the target in which case he should of scored
Silva      32 - Complete game, consistent, just needs to start getting shots on target then the flood gates will open, should of scored. 
Ameobi  32  - Excellent chance at the end of a superb move only 20 seconds in, really definately should of scored, kept going and good skill
Lolley     32 - Hard working, creative, poor shooting, should of scored
Carvalho 10 - Excellent opportunity from 7 yards on the 15th minute, really should of scored, gilt edged, disappeared after we conceded
Grabban 32 - Suffered from dizziness looking high into the sky watching endless shooting stars sailing by, should of scored

I think Ameobi should of scored 20 seconds into the game, it was a beautiful team move and deserved a goal, similar with Carv's chance on 15 minutes, it was an awesome chance.  I think overall it was an excellent effort, cursed in front of goal but could if the team learn and watch it back and see what a chance production line they can be, it was more chances than 6 other games put together, we could go upto a differant level now, you just see!

[Duncan Mckenzie]

Madine spent most of the match rolling on the floor pretending to be in agony if someone brushed against him. Disgraceful player, ref should have booked him for simulation. Thankfully he couldnt score in a brothel anyway.

He's a thug and the EFL should kick him out from the sport.

''Madine has been convicted of several assaults. In November 2010 he was found guilty of causing actual bodily harm after attacking a man in a pub and sentenced to community service involving 250 hours of unpaid work. He was also ordered to pay £1,500 compensation to his victim and £1,800 in costs. In October 2013 he was jailed for 18 months after being found guilty of causing actual bodily harm and grievous bodily harm in two separate attacks Madine was released from jail on 20 February 2014 after serving 5 months of his 18-month sentence''.

[the jock]

hes a scumbag

[zicorice]

Versus Millwall.

Was waiting for this thread as I have now watched back on TV for once confirming real time view. Sorry for stealing someone else's thunder.

Samba 5 Been outstanding, always is but a  couple of off moments tonight, one of which cost us 2 points which we probably didn't deserve.

Cash 6 Overall did quite well defensively and drove forward well, but final ball lacking.

Robinson 5 Not a wing back, looked better when we went to a 4. Got done a few times but Stuck to his task.

Worrall 7 Not as assured in a 3 as he is in a pairing, but made some key tackles. Terrific assist.

Dawson 6 Glad he is back and after a rusty first 30 grew into the game. Starts for me now.

Figuerado 5 Didnt seem to like the formation and made a number of errors. Got beaten too easily. If Cash gets injured Figs definitely can not do a job at RB. Maybe not recovered from Madine mare.

Watson 8 Seemed to be plugging gaps all over the place. On TV also realised how well he is trying to dictate play. Saw some stats that show his winning of possession and completed passes that were staggering. Has buried the summer talk about that holding player required to compete for top 6. It's who plays with him that is the question.

Silva 5 Sees a fair bit of ball and sometimes recycles quite well, but generally buzzed around looking busy but not really achieving alot. Still gives ball away too much. Not his position for this type of game to be fair.

Semedo 5 All 5 marks are for 2nd half. In fairness coming back from injury and didn't affect play at all in 1st 45 minutes. Very lazy defensively again. Made a bit of impact 2nd half.

Ameobi 6 Today was Sami in a nutshell. Mis-controlled ball alot, lost it alot, silly free kicks and almost gave away a pen.......then he turns up, wins a free-kick from which we score and then lays on a plate for Grabs 2nd. Ultimately he has contributed more than most for the point, yet looked crap for 70 mins, but that's our Sami and he deserves to play.

Mir 2 For turning up. It's hard watching him, despite having nothing to feed off, he just doesn't run-unless 5 yards off side. Petulant foul given away. 

Subs
Grabban 9 Does what he does best and nearly won us the game.
Lolley 7 Thought he played well driving us forward.
Adomah 5 Not on long and almost nicked a goal, but not as effective right now as he had been a month or two back.

Sure some will disagree (though probably not about Mir..). I read one poster somewhere saying Silva was our best player tonight for instance. Got to say on 2nd watching I thought he was worse than in real time.  Lots of buzz and no sting for me. Opinions eh?

[the jock]

Samba 6
Cash 6
Worrall 6
Dawson 6
Robinson 5.5
Fig 6
Semedo 5
Silva 5
Watson 8
Ameobi 6
Mir 4

[Sniffer Dog (Admin)]

Samba 6
Cash 6
Worrall 6
Dawson 6
Robinson 5.5
Fig 6
Semedo 5
Silva 5
Watson 8
Ameobi 6
Mir 4

I thought Silva was better than Semedo, a lot better. Also I would give Mir a rating of 1 and I'm being generous.
What did he do to deserve more?

[zicorice]

Samba 6
Cash 6
Worrall 6
Dawson 6
Robinson 5.5
Fig 6
Semedo 5
Silva 5
Watson 8
Ameobi 6
Mir 4

I thought Silva was better than Semedo, a lot better. Also I would give Mir a rating of 1 and I'm being generous.
What did he do to deserve more?

I gave him a 2. 1 for turning up and getting a free-kick. The other one was for kicking a Millwall player. However I knocked off a few for stupidity of the foul too. I originally was going to give 1, but I felt like a 1 has to make  ton of mistakes costing the game and he had no service. I feel I am clutching at straws a bit now.... 4 though Jock? Very generous.

[Username]

Samba 6
Cash 6
Robinson 6
Dawson 7
Worrall 5
Figgy 6
Semedo 4
Silva 7
Watson 8
Ameobi 5
Mir 1

Grabban 8
Lolley 7
Adomah 6

[Salvatore Matrecano]

Samba 6 - Pants or Muric would have been slated on here for the goal he let in
Cash 6
Worrall 6
Dawson 7
Figs 5
Robinson 5 - Got done far too much
Watson 7
Semedo 4- would have got a 1 based on the first half
Silva 6- cant fault his effort but back to giving the ball away constantly. Never stopped trying though.
Ameobi 5 - poor but he was about our only forward threat at times
Mir 3 - Bonatini, Texeira, Mir. Cheers Wolves.

Grabban 8
Lolley 7
Adomah 5 - he can do so much better, should have scored at end.

[Alf]

Samba 6 - Prob his worst game yet, which is saying a lot about how good he's been tbf
Cash 6 - See Samba
Worrall 6 - Poorer than usual in parts, but overall still did ok
Dawson 7 - Good return from the captain. Great to see his passing back in the team
Figs 5 - Poorest of the CB's
Robinson 5 - Meh
Watson 7 - Steady Eddie was steady
Semedo 3 - Awful first half, at least he offered an attacking threat 2nd half. A defensive liability all round though.
Silva 7- Gave the ball away but was lively, tricky & tenacious. Him & Watson looked miles in front of the other midfielders 1st half
Ameobi 6 - Typical Sammy.
Mir 2 - Total waste of a shirt. Should be playing at L1/2 level.

Grabban 9 - Does what he does
Lolley 7 - Looked lively & sharp
Adomah 5 - Was unlucky not to score. Would become twice the player he is had he a proper target man to aim for.