Match Player Ratings

[the jock]

Versus Cardiff. Would like to see other opinions.

Samba 6. Not much to do. Couldn't really do anything about the goal
Cash 6. Too many poor final balls. 6 might be a bit generous
Fig 6 - ok. Madine was winning too much ball too easy. He's not as dominant as Dawson in the air
Worrall - 7 great off the line clearance
Robinson 7;.- great block in second half. Did nothing wrong. Nearly scored. Should keep his place
Watson 8 thought he was excellent. 
Silva 5 - dreadful final ball. Couldn't beat the first man. 
Ameobi 5 - terrible. Could see from the start was one of those days
Lolley 5- trying too hard for a wonder goal. this season has not been great for him
Carvalho 5 - weak influence . The excuses are drying up
Grabban 6 - barely touched the ball. No service

[ThePromisedLand]

Samba 7
Not a great deal to do - but his distribution is still top drawer.

[Alf]

Samba 6 - Steady, as Jock says couldn't do much about the goal
Cash 6 - Steady. Not as threatening as usual, but had our best attempt on target
Figs 4 - Madine handed his arse to him. Didn't play badly, was just outplayed/outmuscled.
Worrall 8 - MOTM, another top game.
Robinson 7 - Good performance, as Jock says deserves to keep his place
Watson 7 - Does what he does
Silva 6 - Thought he did well in a role which isn't really his role.
Ameobi 6 - Threatened at times, but his lack of quality was there to see.
Lolley 6 - Poor first half, better second half and seemed to get better as the game went on.
Carvalho 3 - Crap. Waste of a shirt yesterday.
Grabban 6 - Did what he could with what he got. Did well when having to drop deeper

Semedo 5 - Did OK with what little time he had. Made more of an impact through the fact we now has 3 men in the middle putting it about instead of 2.
Adomah 6 - Did fine with what little time he had. Had he gotten another 20 or so minutes I think one of those crosses would have found a mark.
Mir 4 - Does what Mir does. Nothing lol.

[Derby My Arse]

Samba 6 - Steady, as Jock says couldn't do much about the goal
Cash 6 - Steady. Not as threatening as usual, but had our best attempt on target
Figs 4 - Madine handed his arse to him. Didn't play badly, was just outplayed/outmuscled.
Worrall 8 - MOTM, another top game.
Robinson 7 - Good performance, as Jock says deserves to keep his place
Watson 7 - Does what he does
Silva 6 - Thought he did well in a role which isn't really his role.
Ameobi 6  - Threatened at times, but his lack of quality was there to see.
Lolley 6 - Poor first half, better second half and seemed to get better as the game went on.
Carvalho 3 - Crap. Waste of a shirt yesterday.
Grabban 6 - Did what he could with what he got. Did well when having  to drop deeper

Semedo 5 - Did OK with what little time he had. Made more of an impact through the fact we now has 3 men in the middle putting it about instead of 2.
Adomah 6 - Did fine with what little time he had. Had he gotten another 20 or so minutes I think one of those crosses would have found a mark.
Mir 4 - Does what Mir does. Nothing lol.

Bit harsh on Carvalho I think. It was a poor TEAM performance. Don't think we should signal out individuals.

[Sniffer Dog (Admin)]

Would like to see other opinions

Samba 6. Not much to do. Couldn't really do anything about the goal
Cash 6. Too many poor final balls. 6 might be a bit generous
Fig 6 - ok. Madine was winning too much ball too easy. He's not as dominant as Dawson in the air
Worrall - 7 great off the line clearance
Robinson 7;.- great block in second half. Did nothing wrong. Nearly scored. Should keep his place
Watson 8 thought he was excellent. 
Silva 5 - dreadful final ball. Couldn't beat the first man. 
Ameobi 5 - terrible. Could see from the start was one of those days
Lolley 5- trying too hard for a wonder goal. this season has not been great for him
Carvalho 5 - weak influence . The excuses are drying up
Grabban 6 - barely touched the ball. No service

Nice thread Jock.

Hopefully you will do it every week?

Cheers.

[Alf]

Samba 6 - Steady, as Jock says couldn't do much about the goal
Cash 6 - Steady. Not as threatening as usual, but had our best attempt on target
Figs 4 - Madine handed his arse to him. Didn't play badly, was just outplayed/outmuscled.
Worrall 8 - MOTM, another top game.
Robinson 7 - Good performance, as Jock says deserves to keep his place
Watson 7 - Does what he does
Silva 6 - Thought he did well in a role which isn't really his role.
Ameobi 6  - Threatened at times, but his lack of quality was there to see.
Lolley 6 - Poor first half, better second half and seemed to get better as the game went on.
Carvalho 3 - Crap. Waste of a shirt yesterday.
Grabban 6 - Did what he could with what he got. Did well when having  to drop deeper

Semedo 5 - Did OK with what little time he had. Made more of an impact through the fact we now has 3 men in the middle putting it about instead of 2.
Adomah 6 - Did fine with what little time he had. Had he gotten another 20 or so minutes I think one of those crosses would have found a mark.
Mir 4 - Does what Mir does. Nothing lol.

Bit harsh on Carvalho I think. It was a poor TEAM performance. Don't think we should signal out individuals.

Thought he was awfult tbh mate. One nice ball to Lolley down the right, most other shots, passes, touches etc. were poor.

Thought we looked a much better side when he went off.

[Salvatore Matrecano]

Think most deserved a 6, give Worrall and Watson a 7. We werent that bad yesterday, just got done by an average but physical team that executed their plan very well. No Carvalho was not worse than Lolley, Silva or Ameobi. None of the subs made any impact either.
Interesting point about Figs being found out a bit though, Ive thought before he struggles against a physical forward, other teams will have noticed that.

[the jock]

Will do sniffer

[Redgirl]

I don’t think it was a bad performance it was a typical home performance v Cardiff, the result I expected, I hate playing them, still a cynical Warnock team.

Thought Watson was our best player by a mile, Worrall also did well. Carv was disappointing, he has to take his chances to shine and he isn’t doing. Silva had an off day, the rest of the team were much the same, average.

Just one of those days where I think we could have played until midnight and still not score.

[Sniffer Dog (Admin)]

Will do sniffer

Cheers pal.

[Jasper Scarrott]

Would like to see other opinions

Samba 6. Not much to do. Couldn't really do anything about the goal
Cash 6. Too many poor final balls. 6 might be a bit generous
Fig 6 - ok. Madine was winning too much ball too easy. He's not as dominant as Dawson in the air
Worrall - 7 great off the line clearance
Robinson 7;.- great block in second half. Did nothing wrong. Nearly scored. Should keep his place
Watson 8 thought he was excellent. 
Silva 5 - dreadful final ball. Couldn't beat the first man. 
Ameobi 5 - terrible. Could see from the start was one of those days
Lolley 5- trying too hard for a wonder goal. this season has not been great for him
Carvalho 5 - weak influence . The excuses are drying up
Grabban 6 - barely touched the ball. No service

Looks about right to me.

I would like to see the manager added. I would give Lamouchi a 6. I thought he got it wrong on Saturday.

[wassy04]

Would like to see other opinions

Samba 6. Not much to do. Couldn't really do anything about the goal
Cash 6. Too many poor final balls. 6 might be a bit generous
Fig 6 - ok. Madine was winning too much ball too easy. He's not as dominant as Dawson in the air
Worrall - 7 great off the line clearance
Robinson 7;.- great block in second half. Did nothing wrong. Nearly scored. Should keep his place
Watson 8 thought he was excellent. 
Silva 5 - dreadful final ball. Couldn't beat the first man. 
Ameobi 5 - terrible. Could see from the start was one of those days
Lolley 5- trying too hard for a wonder goal. this season has not been great for him
Carvalho 5 - weak influence . The excuses are drying up
Grabban 6 - barely touched the ball. No service

Looks about right to me.

I would like to see the manager added. I would give Lamouchi a 6. I thought he got it wrong on Saturday.

I’d give him a 5, we were lucky madine got subbed as he completely dominated not only winning headers but actually be able to take the ball down was impressive but disappointing from our perspective. If Figs was getting dominated should’ve put Worrall on him. I thought before the game it was time to
put Dawson back in. 

I think it was clear the tactics of crossing it were not threatening and we really needed more height up top sadly think Mir should’ve come on earlier. Hard to blame him too much for our inability to shoot though, was very frustrating.