07-12-2019, 10:21 AM
(07-12-2019, 09:02 AM)Paplane Wrote: And while im in criticism mode, Rafa Mir. Thanks for your efforts, now piss off, you're not up to the required level. I suggest you look for a league 1 club in January.
The very 1st pass that went into him was spilled and that set the tone for his entire performance. The 3 at the back wod have worked better had Mir been able to take a pass and hold it. And when playing on the left he wasnt tracking back. When he did he was a joke defensivly. The fact that he was shoved out there in the 2nd half speaks volumes for how.poor he was.
He cant finish, he cant play as a sole.striker, he can control the ball, hes physically weak. I just dont see any positive attributes in him.
What efforts?
Also, Semedos performance in comparison to Carvalho last week? Forget price tags (please, just for a moment) Semedo for 50 minutes made a negative contribution. Losing 70 30 duels, giving ball away and not running back towards own goal. Carvalho, had a good ball retention stats, played 2 very good forward passes to open up opponents, 2 shots (one skied admittedly, but other should have been a pen). Worked hard. Also lost his duels and faded, so not a good game by any stretch.
Imagine the stick if Carvhalho had performed lime Semedo did.
Alf is right about loans though. Muric-bin off.
Mir- please bin off.
Semedo-ok if players around him do his dirty work. On a bad day though (eg.Charlton or last night) he is a liability. At least Mir does nothing. Semedo is like a bonus us for the other team on those days. Yet then there is Birmingham and Swansea...
Bostock- not trusted against Cardiff or Millwall despite being built like an athlete probably says what we need to know.