Sean Dyche, Stoney And Woany
(10-01-2026, 12:35 PM)wassy04 Wrote:
(10-01-2026, 12:09 PM)Squarered Wrote: I agree, we can't move onto manager 4 this season. For me Edu carries the can for recruitment this summer which has turned out to be poor and also for disrupting the harmony we had with Nuno in charge. We have gone backwards since his appointment.
McAtee drives me mad, clearly doesn't give a fig about Forest, why did he sign. Thank god MGW signed a new contract, imagine if we were relying on McAtee this season.

Yeah if I was going to sack someone right now I'd go for Edu, more for the Nuno stuff than how the signings have gone. Maybe if we'd just signed bloody Traore we'd be midtable and Kali/Mcatee would be tearing up the league!

I still think Edu signed some good players but for one reason and another we haven't seen them to perform anywhere near their best yet.

Mcatee was captain of England under21's and looked great in the summer playing alongside Anderson and Hutchinson.
Man City also inserted a buy back clause!
If we sell him he will go on and have a good career with a better team than us just like Bade and Kalimuendo.

Say what you want about Zinchenko but he has spent the vast majority of his career playing for the best 2 teams in the PL and possibly two of the best 5 teams in Europe.

Cunha is young and is talented and he should be an investment for the future as should Savona and Bakwa.

Jesus has scored 8 goals now and looks a decent signing but it would help greatly if he wasn't so isolated by our current tactical set up.

Granted John and Ndoye have been disappointed but not all signings work out and that applies at every club in the land not just us.

And fianally Edu's old club Arsenal are currently pissing the PL and favourites to win the CL. Arsenal also wanted to keep him and offered him a new contract. 

But some of you have made up your minds that he is shit and needs sacking which is fair enough but personally he just seems an easy target because people need someone to blame which is once again fair enough.

I am not lauding the bloke far from it but I think he needs far more time to implement his project than what he has been given so far.

Reply
(10-01-2026, 12:49 PM)Sniffer Dog (Admin) Wrote:
(10-01-2026, 12:35 PM)wassy04 Wrote:
(10-01-2026, 12:09 PM)Squarered Wrote: I agree, we can't move onto manager 4 this season. For me Edu carries the can for recruitment this summer which has turned out to be poor and also for disrupting the harmony we had with Nuno in charge. We have gone backwards since his appointment.
McAtee drives me mad, clearly doesn't give a fig about Forest, why did he sign. Thank god MGW signed a new contract, imagine if we were relying on McAtee this season.

Yeah if I was going to sack someone right now I'd go for Edu, more for the Nuno stuff than how the signings have gone. Maybe if we'd just signed bloody Traore we'd be midtable and Kali/Mcatee would be tearing up the league!

I still think Edu signed some good players but for one reason and another we haven't seen them to perform anywhere near their best yet.

Mcatee was captain of England under21's and looked great in the summer playing alongside Anderson and Hutchinson.
Man City also inserted a buy back clause!
If we sell him he will go on and have a good career with a better team than us just like Bade and Kalimuendo.

Say what you want about Zinchenko but he has spent the vast majority of his career playing for the best 2 teams in the PL and possibly two of the best 5 teams in Europe.

Cunha is young and is talented and he should be an investment for the future as should Savona and Bakwa.

Jesus has scored 8 goals now and looks a decent signing but it would help greatly if he wasn't so isolated by our current tactical set up.

Granted John and Ndoye have been disappointed but not all signings work out and that applies at every club in the land not just us.

And fianally Edu's old club Arsenal are currently pissing the PL and favourites to win the CL. Arsenal also wanted to keep him and offered him a new contract. 

But some of you have made up your minds that he is S**t and needs sacking which is fair enough but personally he just seems an easy target because people need someone to blame which is once again fair enough.

I am not lauding the bloke far from it but I think he needs far more time to implement his project than what he has been given so far.

There is no project. He signed Raheem Sterling on loan for Arsenal in a title race. That’s embarrassing.
Reply
(10-01-2026, 12:50 PM)The reds Wrote:
(10-01-2026, 12:49 PM)Sniffer Dog (Admin) Wrote:
(10-01-2026, 12:35 PM)wassy04 Wrote:
(10-01-2026, 12:09 PM)Squarered Wrote: I agree, we can't move onto manager 4 this season. For me Edu carries the can for recruitment this summer which has turned out to be poor and also for disrupting the harmony we had with Nuno in charge. We have gone backwards since his appointment.
McAtee drives me mad, clearly doesn't give a fig about Forest, why did he sign. Thank god MGW signed a new contract, imagine if we were relying on McAtee this season.

Yeah if I was going to sack someone right now I'd go for Edu, more for the Nuno stuff than how the signings have gone. Maybe if we'd just signed bloody Traore we'd be midtable and Kali/Mcatee would be tearing up the league!

I still think Edu signed some good players but for one reason and another we haven't seen them to perform anywhere near their best yet.

Mcatee was captain of England under21's and looked great in the summer playing alongside Anderson and Hutchinson.
Man City also inserted a buy back clause!
If we sell him he will go on and have a good career with a better team than us just like Bade and Kalimuendo.

Say what you want about Zinchenko but he has spent the vast majority of his career playing for the best 2 teams in the PL and possibly two of the best 5 teams in Europe.

Cunha is young and is talented and he should be an investment for the future as should Savona and Bakwa.

Jesus has scored 8 goals now and looks a decent signing but it would help greatly if he wasn't so isolated by our current tactical set up.

Granted John and Ndoye have been disappointed but not all signings work out and that applies at every club in the land not just us.

And fianally Edu's old club Arsenal are currently pissing the PL and favourites to win the CL. Arsenal also wanted to keep him and offered him a new contract. 

But some of you have made up your minds that he is S**t and needs sacking which is fair enough but personally he just seems an easy target because people need someone to blame which is once again fair enough.

I am not lauding the bloke far from it but I think he needs far more time to implement his project than what he has been given so far.

There is no project. He signed Raheem Sterling on loan for Arsenal in a title race. That’s embarrassing.

What about the rest of the squad that he put together or don't they count?

Reply
(10-01-2026, 12:51 PM)Sniffer Dog (Admin) Wrote:
(10-01-2026, 12:50 PM)The reds Wrote:
(10-01-2026, 12:49 PM)Sniffer Dog (Admin) Wrote:
(10-01-2026, 12:35 PM)wassy04 Wrote:
(10-01-2026, 12:09 PM)Squarered Wrote: I agree, we can't move onto manager 4 this season. For me Edu carries the can for recruitment this summer which has turned out to be poor and also for disrupting the harmony we had with Nuno in charge. We have gone backwards since his appointment.
McAtee drives me mad, clearly doesn't give a fig about Forest, why did he sign. Thank god MGW signed a new contract, imagine if we were relying on McAtee this season.

Yeah if I was going to sack someone right now I'd go for Edu, more for the Nuno stuff than how the signings have gone. Maybe if we'd just signed bloody Traore we'd be midtable and Kali/Mcatee would be tearing up the league!

I still think Edu signed some good players but for one reason and another we haven't seen them to perform anywhere near their best yet.

Mcatee was captain of England under21's and looked great in the summer playing alongside Anderson and Hutchinson.
Man City also inserted a buy back clause!
If we sell him he will go on and have a good career with a better team than us just like Bade and Kalimuendo.

Say what you want about Zinchenko but he has spent the vast majority of his career playing for the best 2 teams in the PL and possibly two of the best 5 teams in Europe.

Cunha is young and is talented and he should be an investment for the future as should Savona and Bakwa.

Jesus has scored 8 goals now and looks a decent signing but it would help greatly if he wasn't so isolated by our current tactical set up.

Granted John and Ndoye have been disappointed but not all signings work out and that applies at every club in the land not just us.

And fianally Edu's old club Arsenal are currently pissing the PL and favourites to win the CL. Arsenal also wanted to keep him and offered him a new contract. 

But some of you have made up your minds that he is S**t and needs sacking which is fair enough but personally he just seems an easy target because people need someone to blame which is once again fair enough.

I am not lauding the bloke far from it but I think he needs far more time to implement his project than what he has been given so far.

There is no project. He signed Raheem Sterling on loan for Arsenal in a title race. That’s embarrassing.

What about the rest of the squad that he put together or don't they count?

Arsenal fans will always remember him for not signing a Striker whether or not he built a great squad.
Reply
(10-01-2026, 12:49 PM)Sniffer Dog (Admin) Wrote:
(10-01-2026, 12:35 PM)wassy04 Wrote:
(10-01-2026, 12:09 PM)Squarered Wrote: I agree, we can't move onto manager 4 this season. For me Edu carries the can for recruitment this summer which has turned out to be poor and also for disrupting the harmony we had with Nuno in charge. We have gone backwards since his appointment.
McAtee drives me mad, clearly doesn't give a fig about Forest, why did he sign. Thank god MGW signed a new contract, imagine if we were relying on McAtee this season.

Yeah if I was going to sack someone right now I'd go for Edu, more for the Nuno stuff than how the signings have gone. Maybe if we'd just signed bloody Traore we'd be midtable and Kali/Mcatee would be tearing up the league!

I still think Edu signed some good players but for one reason and another we haven't seen them to perform anywhere near their best yet.

Mcatee was captain of England under21's and looked great in the summer playing alongside Anderson and Hutchinson.
Man City also inserted a buy back clause!
If we sell him he will go on and have a good career with a better team than us just like Bade and Kalimuendo.

Say what you want about Zinchenko but he has spent the vast majority of his career playing for the best 2 teams in the PL and possibly two of the best 5 teams in Europe.

Cunha is young and is talented and he should be an investment for the future as should Savona and Bakwa.

Jesus has scored 8 goals now and looks a decent signing but it would help greatly if he wasn't so isolated by our current tactical set up.

Granted John and Ndoye have been disappointed but not all signings work out and that applies at every club in the land not just us.

And fianally Edu's old club Arsenal are currently pissing the PL and favourites to win the CL. Arsenal also wanted to keep him and offered him a new contract. 

But some of you have made up your minds that he is S**t and needs sacking which is fair enough but personally he just seems an easy target because people need someone to blame which is once again fair enough.

I am not lauding the bloke far from it but I think he needs far more time to implement his project than what he has been given so far.

I agree on the points on the new signings and maintain they made sense, probably would've worked much better if we'd kept Nuno onside. My point was he didn't and made what was clearly a bad situation worse. If Edu had have backed Nuno and signed Traore over Hutchinson then maybe things wouldn't have gone so wrong.
Reply
(10-01-2026, 12:55 PM)The reds Wrote:
(10-01-2026, 12:51 PM)Sniffer Dog (Admin) Wrote:
(10-01-2026, 12:50 PM)The reds Wrote:
(10-01-2026, 12:49 PM)Sniffer Dog (Admin) Wrote:
(10-01-2026, 12:35 PM)wassy04 Wrote: Yeah if I was going to sack someone right now I'd go for Edu, more for the Nuno stuff than how the signings have gone. Maybe if we'd just signed bloody Traore we'd be midtable and Kali/Mcatee would be tearing up the league!

I still think Edu signed some good players but for one reason and another we haven't seen them to perform anywhere near their best yet.

Mcatee was captain of England under21's and looked great in the summer playing alongside Anderson and Hutchinson.
Man City also inserted a buy back clause!
If we sell him he will go on and have a good career with a better team than us just like Bade and Kalimuendo.

Say what you want about Zinchenko but he has spent the vast majority of his career playing for the best 2 teams in the PL and possibly two of the best 5 teams in Europe.

Cunha is young and is talented and he should be an investment for the future as should Savona and Bakwa.

Jesus has scored 8 goals now and looks a decent signing but it would help greatly if he wasn't so isolated by our current tactical set up.

Granted John and Ndoye have been disappointed but not all signings work out and that applies at every club in the land not just us.

And fianally Edu's old club Arsenal are currently pissing the PL and favourites to win the CL. Arsenal also wanted to keep him and offered him a new contract. 

But some of you have made up your minds that he is S**t and needs sacking which is fair enough but personally he just seems an easy target because people need someone to blame which is once again fair enough.

I am not lauding the bloke far from it but I think he needs far more time to implement his project than what he has been given so far.

There is no project. He signed Raheem Sterling on loan for Arsenal in a title race. That’s embarrassing.

What about the rest of the squad that he put together or don't they count?

Arsenal fans will always remember him for not signing a Striker whether or not he built a great squad.

They are pissing the PL and pissing the CL with Edu's squad.

That is the bigger picture not Stirling or a Striker.

Reply
Aye it's not just looking to blame Edu, its the fact that his very appointment brought about the chaos and for what benefit?
Reply
Our whole premier league survival is now in the hands of Edu as far as I can see. Since he's been here he's overseen Nuno go, Ange being appointed & sacked and now Dyche appointed. We were told that he was trying to appoint Mancini but couldn't make it happen. He's sanctioned £170m of transfers, one of whom has left the club already after only playing a handful of times, and of whom a few more received the most direct public criticism a coach can give of them. Everything this guy has done has been a disaster and yet we're expecting him to deliver new players to see us avoid the drop. If we do stay up it will be in spite of him, not because of him.
Reply
(10-01-2026, 01:45 PM)Paplane Wrote: Our whole premier league survival is now in the hands of Edu as far as I can see. Since he's been here he's overseen Nuno go, Ange being appointed & sacked and now Dyche appointed. We were told that he was trying to appoint Mancini but couldn't make it happen. He's sanctioned £170m of transfers, one of whom has left the club already after only playing a handful of times, and of whom a few more received the most direct public criticism a coach can give of them. Everything this guy has done has been a disaster and yet we're expecting him to deliver new players to see us avoid the drop. If we do stay up it will be in spite of him, not because of him.

Lets not pretend Edu has all the power Pap.

Things were going tits up long before Edu rolled into town.

It all went downhill after Leicester at home last season.

Edu tried to stop the downward spiral when he came but a certain manager wouldn't play ball.

Reply
(10-01-2026, 01:15 PM)Sniffer Dog (Admin) Wrote:
(10-01-2026, 12:55 PM)The reds Wrote:
(10-01-2026, 12:51 PM)Sniffer Dog (Admin) Wrote:
(10-01-2026, 12:50 PM)The reds Wrote:
(10-01-2026, 12:49 PM)Sniffer Dog (Admin) Wrote: I still think Edu signed some good players but for one reason and another we haven't seen them to perform anywhere near their best yet.

Mcatee was captain of England under21's and looked great in the summer playing alongside Anderson and Hutchinson.
Man City also inserted a buy back clause!
If we sell him he will go on and have a good career with a better team than us just like Bade and Kalimuendo.

Say what you want about Zinchenko but he has spent the vast majority of his career playing for the best 2 teams in the PL and possibly two of the best 5 teams in Europe.

Cunha is young and is talented and he should be an investment for the future as should Savona and Bakwa.

Jesus has scored 8 goals now and looks a decent signing but it would help greatly if he wasn't so isolated by our current tactical set up.

Granted John and Ndoye have been disappointed but not all signings work out and that applies at every club in the land not just us.

And fianally Edu's old club Arsenal are currently pissing the PL and favourites to win the CL. Arsenal also wanted to keep him and offered him a new contract. 

But some of you have made up your minds that he is S**t and needs sacking which is fair enough but personally he just seems an easy target because people need someone to blame which is once again fair enough.

I am not lauding the bloke far from it but I think he needs far more time to implement his project than what he has been given so far.

There is no project. He signed Raheem Sterling on loan for Arsenal in a title race. That’s embarrassing.

What about the rest of the squad that he put together or don't they count?

Arsenal fans will always remember him for not signing a Striker whether or not he built a great squad.

They are pissing the PL and pissing the CL with Edu's squad.

That is the bigger picture not Stirling or a Striker.

Sorry Sniff but disagree in McAtee. Yes he was the U21 Captain but he was poor all tournament. Anderson, Elliott, Hackney, Livramento and Scott were the standouts and carried him.
Reply
(10-01-2026, 02:09 PM)BomberBowyer Wrote:
(10-01-2026, 01:15 PM)Sniffer Dog (Admin) Wrote:
(10-01-2026, 12:55 PM)The reds Wrote:
(10-01-2026, 12:51 PM)Sniffer Dog (Admin) Wrote:
(10-01-2026, 12:50 PM)The reds Wrote: There is no project. He signed Raheem Sterling on loan for Arsenal in a title race. That’s embarrassing.

What about the rest of the squad that he put together or don't they count?

Arsenal fans will always remember him for not signing a Striker whether or not he built a great squad.

They are pissing the PL and pissing the CL with Edu's squad.

That is the bigger picture not Stirling or a Striker.

Sorry Sniff but disagree in McAtee. Yes he was the U21 Captain but he was poor all tournament. Anderson, Elliott, Hackney, Livramento and Scott were the standouts and carried him.

Indeed he was dropped plenty for Elliot who we could have had for free (or a modest loan fee)
Reply
(10-01-2026, 02:22 PM)DeesideRed Wrote:
(10-01-2026, 02:09 PM)BomberBowyer Wrote:
(10-01-2026, 01:15 PM)Sniffer Dog (Admin) Wrote:
(10-01-2026, 12:55 PM)The reds Wrote:
(10-01-2026, 12:51 PM)Sniffer Dog (Admin) Wrote: What about the rest of the squad that he put together or don't they count?

Arsenal fans will always remember him for not signing a Striker whether or not he built a great squad.

They are pissing the PL and pissing the CL with Edu's squad.

That is the bigger picture not Stirling or a Striker.

Sorry Sniff but disagree in McAtee. Yes he was the U21 Captain but he was poor all tournament. Anderson, Elliott, Hackney, Livramento and Scott were the standouts and carried him.

Indeed he was dropped plenty for Elliot who we could have had for free (or a modest loan fee)

Tbf I read somewhere that Elliott wasn’t interested in coming to us as was worried about our style of play.
Reply


Forum Jump: