26-09-2019, 10:45 AM
(This post was last modified: 26-09-2019, 10:54 AM by Salvatore Matrecano.)
Do we include Semedo in this discussion? He is loaned from Benfica but nationality is Guinea-Bissau. Chema is spanish but what the heck, close enough. Then again Mir is spanish too!
My take on them
Carvalho. 8/10 sometimes I would like him to see him dictate games more but then he will do a sublime pass that takes out the entire defence and then I forgive him pretty much anything.
Ribeiro 7/10 promising start, ball of energy and good attitude and improving with each game so far. Cut out the diving though!
Figs 6.5/10 usually looks tidy enough but has an error in him . Probably needs more game time to improve but I suspect he is 4th choice at the moment. Not a commanding leader like Worrall but very useful back up.
Silva 5/10 I want to like him, he obviously has bags of skill, great with set pieces but gives the ball away sooo much, unfortunately for him he plays in a position where mistakes are often punished. Early days give him more time but we need to some improvement soon to justify a place.
Semedo. 7/10 A bit of an enigma, he either seems to be the best player on the pitch or the worst, nothing in between for Alfa. I still like him, match winner on his day.
Chema cant score him not seen enough, hope his confidence hast been knocked by Tuesday.
My take on them
Carvalho. 8/10 sometimes I would like him to see him dictate games more but then he will do a sublime pass that takes out the entire defence and then I forgive him pretty much anything.
Ribeiro 7/10 promising start, ball of energy and good attitude and improving with each game so far. Cut out the diving though!
Figs 6.5/10 usually looks tidy enough but has an error in him . Probably needs more game time to improve but I suspect he is 4th choice at the moment. Not a commanding leader like Worrall but very useful back up.
Silva 5/10 I want to like him, he obviously has bags of skill, great with set pieces but gives the ball away sooo much, unfortunately for him he plays in a position where mistakes are often punished. Early days give him more time but we need to some improvement soon to justify a place.
Semedo. 7/10 A bit of an enigma, he either seems to be the best player on the pitch or the worst, nothing in between for Alfa. I still like him, match winner on his day.
Chema cant score him not seen enough, hope his confidence hast been knocked by Tuesday.