12-06-2026, 10:47 AM
(11-06-2026, 10:54 PM)stirred Wrote:(11-06-2026, 02:57 PM)Paplane Wrote: If you're old enough to have seen Anderson, Keane, and Collymore play for us in the Premier League, who would you say is/was the best player?
I'm going Collymore>Keane>Anderson. All three were/will be British record sales. So if Anderson is worth £120m, how much would those other two be worth today? Wow, a lot.
I think we had Roy for 3 years, Collymore for 2 and Anderson for 2 (so far). They have 0 Player of the Season awards between them.
Those guys had some excellent team mates.
Yes, they had good team mates but I can still the recall the good impression young Keane made on me when he played his first home game. It was obvious even to my young eye the guy was incredibly talented from the get-go. How the hell we plucked him out of thin air, without any competition from other clubs, I just don't know. He could defend, he could score, could pass and his competitive streak was there too at that young age.
But Collymore could win you a game single handedly. He was hugely talented in that regard. That's why I've got him as our no1 (prem) player.
